HomeScore Landscaping ROI Guide
11 Landscaping Projects Ranked by ROI
The NAR/NALP 2023 survey estimated $900 of recovered value from a $415 lawn program and $50,000 from a $90,000 pool. Use these national benchmarks to compare projects, then weigh your yard, local quotes and the years you expect to enjoy the work.
Create your free account, add your address, and save one major system, like your roof or HVAC, to see its age, cost outlook and next move.
HomeScore Pro is $14/mo. Start Free and add up to 3 systems — no credit card needed. Upgrade to HomeScore Pro when you want the full picture.

Where these numbers come from
NAR + NALP 2023 Remodeling Impact Report: Outdoor Features. NAR and NALP modeled a 2,500-square-foot home on a 14,000-square-foot lot, built after 1978, of typical quality and with no hidden issues. Cost and value-recovered figures are national survey estimates from REALTORS® and landscape professionals — not guaranteed sale-price returns on your property.
These are historical survey benchmarks, not current contractor quotes.
Spend in this order: protect, restore, create, reduce drag, then enjoy
This HomeScore framework prioritizes condition and practical sequencing; it is not a ranking by price or a promise of return.
Protect the property
Anything that stops damage to the structure comes first: hazardous limbs over the roof, drainage running toward the foundation, roots in the sewer line. This spending has no glamour and the best downside math on the page.
Restore the baseline
Lawn care and landscape maintenance return 217% and 104% of modeled cost. Those are the two highest recovery estimates in the report; they are not guaranteed sale outcomes.
Create usable space
A patio (95%, Joy 9.9), a designed landscape upgrade (100%, Joy 9.7) or a deck (89%, Joy 9.8) convert yard into living area. This is the tier where enjoyment and recovery overlap most cleanly.
Reduce operating drag
Irrigation control, right-plant-right-place selection and mulch depth lower the water, time and replacement cost of everything above. Recovery is modest (83% for irrigation); the payoff is the yard not becoming a second job.
Add lifestyle features
Lighting (59%), fire features (56%) and pools (56%) combine high Joy Scores with the lowest recovery estimates. Buy them for the years you will live there, with the recovery gap understood in advance.
All 11 projects, ranked by estimated cost recovered
| Project | 2023 est. cost | 2023 est. value recovered | Recovery | Joy Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard lawn care program | $415 | $900 | 217% | 9.4 / 10 |
| Landscape maintenance | $4,800 | $5,000 | 104% | 9.6 / 10 |
| Overall landscape upgrade | $9,000 | $9,000 | 100% | 9.7 / 10 |
| Outdoor kitchen | $15,000 | $15,000 | 100% | 9 / 10 |
| Patio | $10,500 | $10,000 | 95% | 9.9 / 10 |
| Wood deck | $16,900 | $15,000 | 89% | 9.8 / 10 |
| Tree care | $2,875 | $2,500 | 87% | 9.3 / 10 |
| In-ground irrigation system | $6,000 | $5,000 | 83% | 9.4 / 10 |
| Landscape lighting | $6,800 | $4,000 | 59% | 10 / 10 |
| In-ground pool | $90,000 | $50,000 | 56% | 10 / 10 |
| Fire feature | $9,000 | $5,000 | 56% | 9.7 / 10 |
Survey estimates, not guarantees. Local market, condition, design quality and timing all move the actual number.
Standard lawn care program
The highest-recovery line item in the entire report and the cheapest thing on this page. Fertilization, weed control and consistent mowing restore the condition and appearance of the lawn.
Mistake to avoid: Leaving no time for the work. Turf response depends on season, species, weather and condition; assess the lawn before committing to a listing deadline.
DIY-friendly. Ongoing upkeep: Ongoing seasonal program.
Landscape maintenance
Edging, pruning, mulch, bed definition and clean lines. The 2023 survey estimated slightly more recovered value than cost; local outcomes can differ.
Mistake to avoid: Buying plants before planning bed layout and mature spacing can lead to crowding and extra upkeep.
DIY-friendly. Ongoing upkeep: Seasonal, several times a year.
Overall landscape upgrade
A designed upgrade — structure, layering, walkway and front-entry logic — recovers its full modeled cost. The estimate does not guarantee recovery for an individual design.
Mistake to avoid: Skipping a plan can leave plants unsuited to the site or poorly spaced. Plan for mature size, access and ongoing care.
Mixed. Ongoing upkeep: Moderate: pruning, replacements, mulch.
Outdoor kitchen
Full modeled cost recovery, but the lowest Joy Score on the list. Consider how often your household will cook and host outdoors before committing.
Mistake to avoid: Running gas, water and power without permits or a licensed trade. Unpermitted utility work can create safety, permit and resale complications.
Pro. Ongoing upkeep: Appliance service, winterisation, cover.
Patio
A 95% recovery estimate and 9.9 Joy Score in the 2023 survey make a patio worth comparing with other usable-space options. Site conditions, drainage, construction and permit requirements still matter.
Mistake to avoid: Pouring or setting on unprepared base or toward the house. Bad pitch turns a patio into a water-management problem against your foundation.
Mixed. Ongoing upkeep: Low: sweeping, occasional joint sand or seal.
Wood deck
Nearly the same joy as a patio at higher cost, lower recovery and real ongoing maintenance. Choose a deck when grade, walkout access or a second storey makes a patio impossible.
Mistake to avoid: Ledger attachment and flashing done wrong. These details affect structural safety and moisture control; use qualified help and confirm local requirements.
Pro. Ongoing upkeep: High: clean and re-seal, annual fastener check.
Tree care
The recovery number understates it. Tree care is property protection first — the value is the roof, the sewer line and the car that never get hit.
Mistake to avoid: Topping a mature tree or hiring by lowest price. Bad pruning creates weak regrowth and a larger liability than the branch you removed.
Pro. Ongoing upkeep: Professional assessment based on condition and risk.
In-ground irrigation system
Buy irrigation to protect the lawn and planting investment you already made and to cut operating drag — not for the resale line. It only pays when it is controlled properly.
Mistake to avoid: Setting one schedule and leaving it. The EPA notes that as much as 50% of outdoor water can be wasted through overwatering and inefficiency.
Pro. Ongoing upkeep: Spring start-up, autumn blow-out, head repairs.
Landscape lighting
A perfect 10.0 Joy Score at 59% modeled recovery. This is a lifestyle and safety purchase with a resale side effect, and it should be budgeted as one.
Mistake to avoid: Treating line-voltage lighting as a weekend job. Low-voltage path kits are DIY-reasonable; anything at line voltage or trenched near utilities is not.
Mixed. Ongoing upkeep: Low: lamp replacement, transformer check.
In-ground pool
The largest number on the board and the clearest lifestyle purchase: 56% modeled recovery, a 10.0 Joy Score, plus insurance, safety and operating obligations for as long as you own it.
Mistake to avoid: Budgeting the build and not the decade. Chemicals, power, opening and closing, and eventual liner or surface work are the real cost of ownership.
Pro. Ongoing upkeep: Very high: weekly in season, annual service.
Fire feature
High joy, 56% modeled recovery. Consider it for outdoor enjoyment, with climate, safe clearances and likely use in mind.
Mistake to avoid: Ignoring clearances and gas permitting. Setback rules, combustible surfaces and fuel lines are local-code territory, not catalogue territory.
Pro. Ongoing upkeep: Low to moderate; annual burner service on gas.

Perceived value and sale value
Virginia Cooperative Extension describes a 1999 survey in which respondents rated photographs of the same newly built home with different landscaping. Perceived-value differences between minimal and sophisticated landscaping ranged from 5.5% in Louisiana to 11.4% in South Carolina. These are survey perceptions, not observed sale-price or appraisal gains, and they do not establish the return on a particular design.

Landscape ROI Project Planner
Enable JavaScript to use the five-question planner: ownership horizon, seasonal budget, DIY or hired work, yard condition and your priority. The first ranked move is visible before the optional email unlock for moves two and three.
The line item nobody prices: water and upkeep
EPA says replacing a clock-based irrigation controller with a WaterSense-labeled model can save an average home up to 15,000 gallons a year. Proper installation and programming are important; site conditions, equipment and watering habits affect actual savings.

What changed between the 2018 and 2023 surveys
Two survey snapshots, not a continuous trend. The surveys sampled different respondents.
| Project | 2018 recovery estimate | 2023 recovery estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Standard lawn care | 267% | 217% |
| Landscape maintenance | 100% | 104% |
| Tree care | 100% | 87% |
| Irrigation | 86% | 83% |
Frequently asked questions
Which landscaping project has the highest return on investment?
Standard lawn care. The NAR/NALP 2023 Remodeling Impact Report estimates a $415 program returning $900 of value — 217% of cost, the highest recovery of any outdoor project surveyed. Landscape maintenance (104%) and an overall landscape upgrade (100%) follow. These are national survey estimates on a modeled home, not guaranteed returns on a specific sale.
Does landscaping actually increase home value?
The NAR/NALP 2023 survey reports that 92% of REALTORS® suggest sellers improve curb appeal and 97% call it important. A 1999 photo survey described by Virginia Cooperative Extension found perceived-value differences of 5.5% in Louisiana to 11.4% in South Carolina between minimal and sophisticated landscaping of the same pictured home. Those are respondents' perceptions, not measured sale-price or appraisal gains.
Is a pool a good investment for resale?
The NAR/NALP 2023 survey estimated a $90,000 in-ground pool recovering $50,000 — 56% of cost — with a 10.0 Joy Score. That benchmark favors treating a pool as an enjoyment decision, with local demand, insurance, safety and operating costs assessed separately. It does not predict your sale result.
Should I landscape before selling my house?
Start by assessing condition, budget and time before listing. Lawn care and landscape maintenance had the highest recovery estimates in the 2023 survey. Pools, fire features and lighting had lower estimates; an outdoor kitchen was estimated at 100%, so it is not in that lowest-recovery group. Obtain local advice and quotes before a major project.
What landscaping can I safely do myself?
Lawn programs, mulching, bed edging, planting, and low-voltage path lighting are reasonable DIY. Tree work at height, line-voltage electrical, gas lines for fire features and outdoor kitchens, structural deck framing and ledger attachment, and anything trenched near utilities are not. Call 811 before any digging.
How much water does an irrigation system waste?
EPA estimates that as much as 50% of water used outdoors can be wasted through inefficient watering. Replacing a clock-based controller with a WaterSense-labeled model can save an average home up to 15,000 gallons a year. Proper installation and programming matter; actual savings depend on the site, equipment and watering practices.